***Author's note: Below you will find two different rankings for this year's albums. And what a year it has been! Definitely one of the best years collectively that I have ever heard--even to rival (or surpass) 2007, 2011, 2013, 1973 and even 1972!
The first list consists merely of a Top 40 with a following list of "Honorable Mentions." These are my favorite albums of the year, that is, the albums to which I have formed the greatest emotional attachments. The Reviews that follow, however, are ordered according to my more 'objective' yet personal judgment as to their quality, that is, the "best" albums of the year. Here I have tried to order the albums reviewed according to the determinations of my personal metric system (the "FishScales"). Thus, the albums I have listed are the "best" albums of the year from a more critical, qualitative, and quantitative viewpoint, that is, without as much emotional attachment as "My Favorite" albums. My thanks, once again, go out to the wonderful community at ProgArchives.com as well as to the tremendous resource that is updated daily called New Prog Releases (http://newprogreleases.blogspot.com/p/2018.html).
I have listened to over 175 studio albums released in 2015 and posted reviews of about 60 of them. According to my calculations, 2015 presents Prog World with four (4) full masterpieces, 15 "minor" masterpieces, and 15 "near-masterpieces"!
(My "Favorites")
2. ALIO DIE & LORENZO MONTANÀ Holographic Codex
3. BATTLESTATIONS The Extent of Damage
4. STEVEN WILSON Hand. Cannot. Erase.
5. MYSTERY Delusion Rain
6. ANEKDOTEN Until the Ghosts Have All Gone
7. ANNA VON HAUSSWOLFF The Miraculous
8. SYLVAN Home
11. THE AMAZING Picture You
13. KLONE Here Comes the Sun
14. ZA! Loloismo
15. ABIGAIL'S GHOST Black Plastic Sun
16. PROGRESSION BY FAILURE Sonic Travelogue
17. NEEDLEPOINT Aimless Mary
20. MONOBODY Monobody
24. THIEVES' KITCHEN The Clockwork Universe
27. NEMO Coma
28. CICCADA The Finest of Miracles
29. JAM IT! Following the Unknown
33. HOMUNCULUS RES Come si diventa ciò che si era
34. CORVUS STONE Unscrewed
35. MANNA/MIRAGE Blue Dogs
36. TOE Hear You
37. ABSTRAKT Limbosis
38. ADVENT The Silent Sentinel
39. NATIVE CONSTRUCT Quiet World
Honorable Mentions:
KARDA ESTRA Strange Relations
LA CURVA DI LESMO La Curva di Lesmo
Precisely performed jazzy Math Rock from some youth from Chicago. Gutsy, intelligent, complex and intricate yet delivered tight and with great melodic sense.
1. "Lifeguard of a Helpless Body" (4:15) with the same fast pace and upbeat nature of a TOE (Japan) jam, this sets the tone for the album with some fast-picking (and tapping) guitar work. Such a refreshing sound! (10/10)
- Nikitas Kissonas / electric, acoustic & Classical guitars, composer, arranger & producer
With:
- Joe Payne / vocals
- Linus Kåse / keyboards, synthesizers, grand piano
- Nikos Zades / sound design
- Brett d'Anon / bass
- Mickael Walle Wahlgren / drums
- Lu Jeffery / violin
- Bernard Kane Jr / viola
- Juliet McCarthy / cello
- Ron Phelan / double bass
Brass Quintet:
- Tom Heath / trumpet
- Catriona Christie / trumpet
- Nerys Russell / horn
- James Patrick / trombone
- Alistair Clements / tuba
4. CICADA Light Shining Through the Sea
Light Shining through the Sea is a stunningly beautiful collection of songs released in September of this year. This album has really connected with me--much moreso than the band's last two albums. I attribute this fact to the new level of maturity in both composition and instrumental contributions of each of the band's five. Veering more and more away from the repetitive Post Rock/Math Rock stylings that the band has been pigeon-holed with since the release of their 2010 debut, Over the Sea/Under the Water, this album sees much more variation in styles, transitions, moods and while still maintaining--no, far exceeding the high standards of composition and musicianship established by all of their previous albums. Light Shining through the Sea even shows some experimentation with expansion beyond the usual quintet form. But more, the contributions of violin, viola, cello, and guitar are all much more unique and individualistic instead of feeling as if they are just part of composer Jesy Chiang's mind (and more than substantial heart).
The "Minor" Masterpieces
Now this is a Progressive Rock album! Great mix of styles and moods and lots of instrumental choices and stylings that are fairly fresh for Anekdoten. I guesss the eight years off tending to other projects served Nicklas, Ana Sofia, Jan Erik and Peter well.
91.80 on the Fish scales = five stars; a minor masterpiece of progressive rock music theater.
With The extent of damage, Battlestations have put on display the fact that they have become masters of painting pictures—moving pictures—adventures!—with music.
Ambient music in the vein of BRIAN ENO's 1982 classic, Ambient 4: On Land, seasoned electronica veteran Alio Die teams up with countryman Lorenzo Montanà who is more known for his film scoring. The collaboration is perfect as Alio Die's typical Arabian-indfused heavily treated zither, voice, and percusssives are mixed and diluted with M. Montanà's contributions, making them more ethereal and more effective. All but one of the song compositions rate exceedingly high in their capacity to engage and interest the listener.
1. "Muns de Etrah" (6:56) is beautiful in a peaceful, angelic way using treated organ, wind sounds, computer clicks, treated percussion, processed zithers and more. Gorgeously layered and flowing song. (10/10)
2. "Hydra e Vers" (5:16) is dark and brooding in a BRIAN ENO Ambient 4: On Land kind of way using what sounds like Islamic chants, prayers or calls to prayer. (9/10)
3. "Akvil" (9:35) starts out uplifting in a meditative way with church bells as if at the end of a wedding or high mass but then turns subtly in a darker direction around the 2:30 mark with a sub-layer of sound that at first creeps in and eventually becomes the dominant mood driver. (18/20)
4. "Silent Rumon" (15:16) is ominously laden with a full orchestra-like feel and a subtle yet driving Berlin School electronic percussion. This feels like a KLAUS SCHULZE classic. The use of Arabian voices, sounds, and melodic patterns is quite prevalent in this one. (30/30)
5. "Egetora" (5:24) not the prettiest or most engaging nor relaxing song. The music is so ethereal, so distant and almost pitchless that it almost fails to qualify as music! But it does produce an ambient space, with a limbo-like feel in a way that only Brian Eno has done well. It's like being in Purgatory: We are waiting and waiting--we are all waiting! (7/10)
6. "Cinta della Breccia Divina" (15:14) wind and pulsating drones give this an On Land feel to it. Even rejoinder of the ambient and incidental zither makes it feel Eno-esque--kind of like Ambient 3: Day of Radiance, Eno's recording of the music of African-American street musician, zither player Laraaji. (26/30)
7. "Eternal Wisdom" (6:12) embraces the angelic in a European cathedral choir practice kind of way. From the uplifting opening chord to its end. (10/10)
I have to say, the fact that I keep playing this CD for background music everyday while doing our farm wash'n'packs says a lot about its effect. It offends no one and adds a bit of the dramatic-contemplative to our day. This is definitely one of the best ambient albums I've heard in a long time (And I'm so glad ambient is an accepted sub-category of the prog rock sub-genre "electronic.")
91.67 on the Fishscales = A-; a minor masterpiece of progressive rock and deep ambient music.
Axeman extraordinaire Colin Tench has gotten busy in the engineering room! And I LIKE IT! The “new” sound Colin has produced here is wonderfully reminiscent of the pre-computer-enhanced days of sound (re-)production (i.e. before the Fairlight CMI, gated drums, PC home studio software, and the now ubiquitous sound compression). I just love listening to the drums and percussion! It reminds me of being in one room playing and recording with my brothers: the sound is all right there with you, not compartmentalized and isolated in different “rooms”. It’s like capturing live performances! Which is ironically wonderful for the fact that Colin and his bandmates, I believe, live in widely distant locations and, therefore, submit their instrumental contributions over the internet (or by mail).
Five star songs: the amazingly fitting soundtrack song, “Scary Movie Too” (7:38); the powerful opening instrumental, “Brand New Day” (3:52); the awesomely multiple vocals of “Early Morning Calls” (3:52); the crystal clarity of every instrument on “Horizon” (1:52); the medieval folk feel to the foundation of “Landfill” (3:44); the wonderful multiple melody lines and multiple tempos of “After Solstice (Remix)” (4:05); the awesome Al Di MELOA/James Bond-like theme song, “Petrified in the Cinema Basement” (3:10); the organ and military drum base and late Sixties feel of “Lost and Found Revisited” (3:29); the virtuosic guitar showcased on both “Cinema Finale” (6:02) and “Pack up your Truffles” (2:07), and; the rollicking fun and humor of “Moustaches in Massachusetts” (4:18).
91.54 on the Fish scales = A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of prog rock.
Line-up / Musicians:
- Jean Pageau / lead vocals, keyboards, flute
- Michel St-Père / electric & acoustic guitars, keyboards, producer
- Sylvain Moineau / electric guitar, 12-string acoustic guitar
- Benoît Dupuis / keyboards
- François Fournier / bass, Taurus pedals, keyboards
- Jean-Sébastien Goyette / drums
With:
- Antoine Michaud / guitars
- Sylvain Descôteaux / piano
1. "Delusion Rain" (10:04) A solid song that just never elevates itself into heavenly standards of memorability. (17.5/20)
2. "If You See Her" (6:11) A prog ballad by-the-numbers but done to perfection. The keyboard embellishments and restrained guitar soli (especially in the fifth minute) are wonderful. (9/10)
3. "The Last Glass of Wine" (6:47) Great pacing, great singing and lyrics, incredibly engaging chord progressions and melodic hooks, amazing sound and instrumental clarity, and hugely chunky bass, and yet nothing over-the-top or overdone. This is about as good as Neo Prog can get. (15/15)
4. "The Willow Tree" (19:30) A few choices misfire and a few opportunities were missed--and it may drag on a bit longer than it needs to, but, still, overall, another beautiful and wonderfully restrained presentation. "Have you seen your eyes" is definitely a brainworm. (37.5/40)
5. "Wall Street King" (6:39) Despite the cogent topic, pleasant opening and great fifth minute, this is one of the weaker songs on this otherwise stunning album. (8.75/10)
6. "A Song for You" (12:35) is a little on the cliché bombastic side, but I cannot argue with the gorgeous melodies, heart-wrenching chord progressions, tasteful guitar soli and amazing synth soli. Change the first 6:15 a bit and you have an outright masterpiece. (22/25)
Total Time 61:46
91.46 on the Fish scales = A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece and another wonderful contribution to the world of progressive rock music from these masters of Neo Prog.
Sorry, Thomas, but this, Delusion Rain, is the greatest Neo Prog album ever made. (Just kidding. That honor would have to go to either Moonshine or Seven.) If all Neo Prog were like this, I might like more of it.
Impressive avant prog metal vaudeville from Berklee College of Music students. (One can even watch YouTube videos of the boys playing and recording their parts in some tiny dormroom on campus.)
Line-up / Musicians:
- Robert Edens / Vocals
- Myles Yang / Guitar
- Max Harchik / Bass
1. "Mute" (6:21) opens just like a Devy Townsend piece--something from one of his more comedic entertainment classics like Ziltoid--but then at 1:35 the more theatric, QUEEN-cabaret-like stuff begins--it even sounds like a modern Brian May playing some of the guitar parts. At 2:58 vocalist Robert Edens launches into a very engaging multi-track vocal "chant"-like passage which is joined by a gradually ever-expanding field of jazzy orchestral instruments. By the end of the fifth minute the music has blossomed into a kind of Golden Age of Broadway 1950s grandiosity but then at 5:15 growl vocals, metal machine gun bass drumming and multiple electric guitars (some of which still sound Brian May-ish) explode into the track to finish the song with some modern youthful force. Very interesting and often amazing song. A top three song for me. (9.25/10)
2. "The Spark Of The Archon" (8:50) more retro-prog metal schmaltz. The combination of stop-and-go, quick-changing heavy metal structure and sound with classic jazz and Broadway melody making and stylings is quite unusual and remarkable; there are very few artists that come to mind when trying to compare this music-making style (one of which is Devin Townsend). This song does not have so much variation as the opener but continues to carve out quite an unique path for itself--especially with its melodramatic final minute. It is also filled with occasional moments of breathtaking genius, beauty, and emotion. (17.75/20)
3. "Passage" (8:07) toy piano and bassoon open this before oboe (and, later, bowed double bass) joins in to form a weave that sounds more Present/Univers Zero. After 90 seconds of this introductory overture, vocalist Robert Edens joins in, singing in a style more befitting the 1920s or 1930s. But then, around 2:05 the big band music expands with some (more) Brian May like guitar and militaristic drumming with the keyboard orchestration before crescendoing in some more metallic bursts. The music settles back into a most unusual jazz-metal sound palette as the vocalist and other instruments trade solos--until, that is, a harp bridge at 5:05 into a (13.5/15)
4. "Your Familiar Face" (4:11) A more poppy, QUEEN-like song, only, with all of the sharp edges, twists and turns of more modern metal music. I just love the multi-track vocal chanting that the band uses over the European jazzy soundscapes. My favorite song on the album. (9.25/10)
5. "Come Hell Or High Water" (5:54) a rapid-fire, twisting and turning metal song that reminds me of the stylings and humor of MR. BUNGLE and HUMBLE GRUMBLE. Man! Myles sure loves that Brian May sound! (8.875/10)
6. "Chromatic Lights" (2:14) bass and two guitars weaving ostinato melodies like a classical chamber trio. Is the crackling in the sound an attempt to throw back to the recorded music of Django Reinhardt and Stéphane Grappelli? (4.3333/5)
7. "Chromatic Aberration" (12:28) quite a suite! Opening with the melody lines of the previous song, only rendered unto keyboard, the song travels on a what feels like a hero's quest journey: encountering and surmounting many obstacles as one would working one's way through a video game. The soundtrack to the "mind game" with his giant adversary and Formic queen that Andrew Wiggin is subjected to during his "down time" at Battle School training program in both the book and film of Orson Scott Card's Ender's Game. (22.25/25)
Total Time 48:05
The question is: Are these guys joking or will we hear more (and better) stuff like this from them in the future? The quirky changes and total mood shifts mid song--multiple times--makes one wonder what the goals/aims of these shifts are? It's almost as if multiple personalities are each given their turn at presenting the song's message. Interesting but often a bit jarring, unsettling (though never so much as in an UneXpect song). The overriding sentiment is, however, that this album's music is certainly memorable.
After years of living with this album, revisiting it several times (and feeling haunted by its very memorable and unique music), I've come to the conclusion that there is the music is steeped in some deep and complexly varied musical histories coming from each of its creators: a lot of knowledge of classical, Broadway/stage, ethnic, and, of course, metal traditions was necessary to create this very mature and complex (and theatric) music. Mega kudos to Robert, Max, and Myles, wherever you are. I think you created with your college dormroom album some kind of feat of wonder--perhaps even a masterpiece; one for the ages.
BTW: bassist Max Harchick is AMAZING!
91.01 on the Fishscales = A-/five stars; a minor masterpiece of intricately nuanced theatric prog metal; highly recommended for all prog lover's--an experience you will not soon forget.
90.95 on the Fish scales = five stars; a minor masterpiece of folk-based progressive rock music.
One of the things I had to get used to in this album is the “scantly clad“ music presented here: there are very few added layers or fluffy fills and incidentals in these songs. Each song feels rather stripped down, bare, and naked. And clean. The drums feel live. The vocals feel live. The acoustic guitars feel live. Like the recently released CORVUS STONE surprise, Unscrewed, 3RDegree seems to have gravitated to a pre-computerized recording/engineering style—which I love! Every sound is crystal clear and feeling as if you are in the room with it—as if the band is playing live, in the same room, with each other. Other than ECHOLYN, STEELY DAN, early DAVID BOWIE, or the occasional flash of CARAVAN or PETER MURPHY, I can’t find myself feeling many immediate associations with the music on Ones & Zeros. It’s just good, unusual, fresh and original music—on the pop side of prog.
90.0 on the Fish scales = A-/five stars.
2. "Sea Breeze" (7:16) continues to put on display the band's complex and tight tempo and chordal changes--but, though impressive, this is nothing so very new or exciting. Yet. (12.5/15)
3. "Through The Forest" (6:30) opens a bit like a CORVUS STONE song, rockin' bluesy with the COLIN TENCH guitar sound. It goes through a few shifts over the simple bass line and stumbling drum line. This is, for me, the "breakout song" in which the band shows some of its uniqeness. There are interesting tempo and key shifts, interesting keyboard choices and passages, and frequent melody shifts as well. The duplicated keyboard-guitar riffs in the fifth minute are awesome--and they're followed immediately by some awesome power chords before a piano-based section takes over. Soon bass and drums kick up a groove over which the guitar and piano rip. Awesome song! My third favorite on the album. (9/10)
4. "Mountain Of Solitude" (9:33) is the first song in which I feel as if the band members have set up a goal or study of an idea--as if they are practicing some concept from music theory. A relatively slow tempo song, the band amps up the volume around the 3:45 mark--with Konstantin's guitar, of course, taking the lead--but not for long, as the song quickly returns to étude mode though with increasingly heaviness--building toward a guitar harmonics bridge at the five minute mark that precedes another classic bluesy pitch-bending and chord-interspersed guitar solo. Stevie Ray would be proud! I love the collective control and discipline exhibited in this one. Alexey is awesome in the background! I'd love to see him and Gavin HARRISON or Vinny COLAIUTA trade punches! (18/20)
5. "Avalanche" (7:24) opens with an Alexey solo establishing the mixed-meter tempo. The rest of the band soon arrive and eventually establish some nice, complex melodies through chordal progression and instrumental interplay. Really interesting! Konstantin almost gets unleashed a couple of times until the fourth minute when tempo and mood downshift to something very pretty and simple--but not for long! A heavier expression of this same slowed down section establishes itself before alternating back and forth with the pretty section. But then, surprise, some awesome djenty guitar and bass open the door for some odd drum soloing by Alexey. Konstatin's guitar soon tries to take the lead but Alexey seems to fight him for it! Awesome! Alexey is going crazy as the band launches a new almost RPI-like section up to the end. Great song! (13.5/15)
6. "Into The Mist" (5:07) opens as a kind of gentle chordal and rhythmic etude. By the time the song gels into its second round of the study after the first "chorus" their is some significant and beautiful development. Starting at the 2:15 mark the song begins to amp up with some amazing bass and guitar play (as Alexey lays back). When Konstantin hits some amazing notes at the end of the fourth minute the 'étude' feels as if it is building, gradually filling all of the "empty" space that the opening section had displayed to the point that it is very full, but not too busy or loud by the end. It all works wonderfully! A top three song for me. (10/10)
7. "Random Name Hero" (12:22) This is the song whose surprising chord progressions are surprisingly melodic--even replete with delightful Asian tendencies. A true West-meets-East contrivance. I love it! It starts out rather mundanely but by the second minute unfolds into a wonderfully entertaining and engaging song. By the six and seventh minutes enough interplay has been displayed to allow the individuals to go on to some nice soli--bass, keys, and awesome classic rock-like blues guitar. Roman's keyboard support throughout this one is, I have to admit, quite extraordinary. And Alexey's military-founded rhythmics are, of course, in a league all their own. Wow! Another top three song. (24/25)
SPECIAL CONTRIBUTION TO MUSIC IN THE AREA OF ORIGINAL MOVIE SOUNDTRACK:
ALEXANDRE DESPLAT The Danish Girl
Once in a great while a film is so enhanced by its musical soundtrack as to make it bigger, better and more impactful than it would be without it. The The Danish Girl is truly a cinematic marvel--the acting, cinematography and editing are truly exquisite--but Alexandre Desplat's brilliant soundtrack is gorgeous beyond words. Each scene is enhanced artistically--in beauty, and in emotional power and depth--by the melodic, sometimes minimalist jazz contributions of Maestro Desplat. From the very first opening theme of the movie I knew I was in for something special: that the music was going to suck me into this film as deeply as I can go. And it did. Without question or hesitation I can say that The Danish Girl was both my favorite and the best movie that I saw from 2015--and the soundtrack lives on as one of my all-time favorites.
I'm using your post to help make a list of great albums of 2015 that I missed but will want to check out. I only bought about eight new releases last year. This list and the PA top 100 of 2015 will help me catch up.
ReplyDelete