Friday, April 18, 2014

My All-Time Favorite Albums

Here is my List of All-Time Favorites. I've been working on this for several years now, going over and over it almost every week, so the list is by now fairly accurate up to date. Enjoy! 

1. The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway—Genesis
2. Mëkanïk Dëstruktïw Kömmandöh—Magma
3. Shiny Eyed Babies––Bent Knee
4. Limiti all'egualianza della parte con il tutto––Homunculus Res
5. Dots and Loops—Stereolab
6. Don Juan’s Reckless Daughter—Joni Mitchell
7. Jan Akkerman—Jan Akkerman
8. Tiny Dynamine/Echoes on A Shallow Bay—Cocteau Twins
9. Novella—Renaissance
10. Chakradancer—Brainscapes (Alain Eskinasi)
11. Gentle Stream—The Amazing
12. Brilliant Trees—David Sylvian
13. Disintegration—The Cure
14. The Look of Love—Diana Krall
15. Love Deluxe––Sade
16. Treasure—Cocteau Twins
17. Adventures in Utopia—Todd Rundgren’s Utopia
18. Boy—U2
19. Reach The Beach—The Fixx
20. The Dream Academy—The Dream Academy
21. Lost Souls––doves
22. Strange Kind of Love––Love and Money
23. Todd—Todd Rundgren
24. Idlewild––Everything But The Girl
25. Pelican West—Haircut One Hundred
26. Not This City––Five-Storey Ensemble
27. Gone to Earth—David Sylvian
28. Eli—Jan Akkerman & Kaz Lux
29. A Charlie Brown Christmas—Vince Guaraldi Trio
30. It's Better to Travel––Swing Out Sister
31. Ambient 2: The Plateaux of Mirror—Harold Budd & Brian Eno
32. America—America
33. Animals—Pink Floyd
34. Puccini: Great Arias—London Records
35. Nina Hagen Band—Nina Hagen Band
36. Hergest Ridge—Mike Oldfield
37. What’s Goin’ On—Marvin Gaye
38. Gregorian Chant—Choralschola der Wiener Hofburgkapelle
39. Indian Summer––Landberk
40. The Mad Hatter––Chick Corea
41. Shadows of The Sun—Ulver
42. The Last Broadcast—doves
43. The Hurting—Tears for Fears
44. Open Sky––Iona
45. The Difference Machine—Big Big Train
46. Natural Elements—Shakti
47. Odyssey: The Greatest Tale––Colossus Magazine/Musea Records
48. UK—UK
49. The Geese and The Ghost—Anthony Phillips
50. A Trick of The Tail—Genesis

51. Mozart's 23 Piano Concertos––Alfred Brendel, Neville Marriner and The Academy of St. Martin-in the-Fields; Phillips, 1991.
52. Everything But The Girl (debut album, U.S. release)—Everything But The Girl
53. Selling England by The Pound—Genesis
54. Crime of The Century—Supertramp
55. Aja—Steely Dan
56. Bar-do Travel––Proghma-C
57. The Last Samurai Soundtrack—Hans Zimmer
58. The Final Breath Before November––Edison's Children
59. Vaughn Williams––Iona Brown, violin, Neville Marriner and The Academy of St. Martin-in-the-Fields; Argos, 1972.
60. Mind Fruit—Opus III
61. Pastorales de Noël—Michel LeGrande, Jean-Pierre Rampal, LeGoya
62. Picchio dal Pozzo––Picchio dal Pozzo
63. The Danish Girl Original Motion Picture Soundtrack––Alexandre Desplat
64. Secret Story—Pat Metheny 
65. Porcelain––Julia Fordham
66. A Rare Moment of Insight—Brother Ape
67. A Tab in The Ocean—Nektar
68. Si on avait besoin d’une cinqième saison—Harmonium
69. Walking Wounded—Everything But The Girl
70. Light Shining Through the Sea––Cicada
71. Caravanserai—Santana
72. Cosmic Messenger—Jean-Luc Ponty
73. Space Shanty—Khan
74. LightDark—NoSound
75. Ga'an––Ga'an
76. Henryk Górecki's Symphony No. 3, Op. 36––Joanna  Koslowska, soprano, Karimierz Kord and the Warsaw Philharmonic Orchestra; Decca, 1992.
77. The Dreaming—Kate Bush
78. Four-Calendar Café––Cocteau Twins
79. Eve—Karda Estra
80. Espectro––Violeta de Outono
81. Fragile—Yes
82. Hamburger Concerto—Focus
83. Renaissance of The Celtic Harp—Alan Stivell
84. Harvest Moon––Votum
85. New Gold Dream—Simple Minds
86. Part The Second—maudlin of The Well
87. Mirabilis—Mediaeval Baebes
88. Codename: Dustsucker—Bark Psychosis
89. Timeloss—Päatos
90. Ram—Paul & Linda McCartney
91. Scheherazade and Other Stories—Renaissance
92. Songs of Robert Burns—Andy Stewart
93. Swept—Julia Fordham
94. Trespass—Genesis
95. Omphalos—Kotebel
96. Discipline—King Crimson
97. Foxtrot—Genesis
98. If_then_else—The Gathering
99. Remain in Light—Talking Heads
100. Dark Side of The Moon—Pink Floyd

101. Close to The Edge—Yes
102. The Court of The Crimson King—King Crimson
103. Eden––Faun
104. Playing The Piano––Ryuichi Sakamoto
105. The Following Morning—Eberhard Weber
106. As Falls Wichita, So Falls Wichita Falls—Pat Metheny & Lyle Mays
107. Jam on Revenge—Newcleus
108. The Dark Third—Pure Reason Revolution
109. Mourning Sun––Fields of the Nephilim
110. Demons and Wizards—Uriah Heep
111. Romantic Warrior—Return to Forever
112. Butch Cassidy and The Sundance Kid soundtrack––Burt Bacharach
113. Nursery Cryme—Genesis
114. Long Distance—Ivy
115. Déjà Vu—Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young
116. Shake It Up––Boney James & Rick Braun
117. Blue Bell Knoll––Cocteau Twins
118. Sound Mirrors––Syd Arthur
119. Days of Future Passed––Moody Blues
120. The Rite of Strings—Jean-Luc Ponty, Al DiMeola, Stanley Clarke
121. October—U2
122. ~ – iamthemorning
123. At The Village Vanguard—Bill Evans Trio
124. Falling Deeper––Anathema
125. The Love Connection—Freddie Hubbard
126. Constellations—Karda Estra
127. Postaeolian Train Robbery––Cos
128. Chicago Transit Authority—Chicago
129. Innervisions—Stevie Wonder
130. Blade Runner soundtrack—Vangelis
131. A Gift of Love—Deepak Chopra & Friends
132. Vimana—Nova
133. December—George Winston
134New Wave––Soul Family Sensation
135. Relayer—Yes
136. Interior City––The Gabriel Construct
137. Interstellar Original Soundtrack––Hans Zimmer
138. Illustrated Musical Encyclopedia—Ryuichi Sakamoto
139. Over the Sea/Under The Water—Cicada
140. Everyone into Position—Oceansize
141. Vespertine—Björk
142. Mais on ne peut pas rêver tout le temps––Laurent Thibault
143. Ghost in the Machine—The Police
144. Metamorphosis––Axon-Neuron
145. Stealing Fire—Bruce Cockburn
146. Moving Waves—Focus
147. Tales of Mystery & Imagination—Alan Parsons Project
148. Even in The Quietest Moments—Supertramp
149. The Sensual World—Kate Bush
150. Café Bleu––The Style Council

151. The Polite Force––Egg

153. Trance Tara––Jonathan Goldman
154. No Borders Here—Jane Siberry
155. Music for 18 Musicians—Steve Reich
156. Winter Dreams––R. Carlos Nakai & William Eaton
157. Symphony No. 3 in F major, Op. 90—Johannes Brahms
158. Initiation—Todd Rundgren
159. Fiori, frutti, farfalle––Humana Prog
160. Lighthouse––iamthemorning
161. Off The Wall—Michael Jackson
162. Steve McQueen—Prefab Sprout
163. I Robot—Alan Parsons Project
164. Peaceful Evening––Steve & David Gordon
165. Preda—Mad Crayon
166. Venusian Summer––Lenny White
167. Unsound—Funin
168. Ghosts Don't Dance with Shoes––Tree Tops
169. Guérison––Setna
170. Time Control—Hiromi’s Sonicbloom
171. The Year of The Cat—Al Stewart
172. Aerial––Kate Bush
173. Antiphon––Midlake
174. Hex––Bark Psychosis
175. One World––John Martyn
176. Ur—Steve Tibbetts
177. Leaving Your Bodymap—maudlin of The Well
178. Mummer––XTC
179. Boston—Boston
180. Janet.––Janet Jackson
181. High Land, Hard Rain—Aztec Camera
182. In The Wee Small Hours—Frank Sinatra
183. Le quattro stagioni—Vivaldi
184. Talsette di Marsantino––L'Estate di San Martino
185. Moonshine—Collage
186. Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots—The Flaming Lips
187West Indian Girl—West Indian Girl
188. Houses of The Holy—Led Zeppelin
189. Change We Must—Jon Anderson
191. Nil novo sub sole––Nil
192. One Man Tells Another––Landberk
193. Emerson Lake & Palmer—Emerson Lake & Palmer
194. The Moon and The Melodies—Cocteau Twins and Harold Budd
195. A Distant Shore––Tracy Thorn
196. Per un amico—PFM
197. Mother Focus––Focus
198. Amplified Heart—Everything But The Girl
199. Le Horla—The Box
200. Sound-Dust—Stereolab

201. Kaleidoscope World––Swing Out Sister
202. III—Focus
203. Equations of Meaning--Tony Patterson
204. Skylarking—XTC
205. Fear of A Blank Planet—Porcupine Tree
206. Overground Music––After Crying
207. Kind of Blue—Miles Davis
208. Magical Mystery Tour—The Beatles
209. Big Circumstance—Bruce Cockburn
210. Infernal Machina—Jannick Top
211. Mozart's Clarinet & Bassoon Concertos––Jack Brymer/Gwydion Brooke, Thomas Beecham and The Royal Philharmonic Orchestra; EMI.
212. City of the Sun––Seven Impale
213. Incantations––Mike Oldfield
214. The Stranger—Billy Joel
215. Jurassic Shift—Ozric Tentacles
216. Parsley, Sage, Rosemary & Thyme—Simon & Garfunkle
217. Spectral Mornings—Steve Hackett
218. Extra Virgin—Olive
219. Tingri—Jonn Serrie
220. Pamiec--SBB
221. Temperamental—Everything But The Girl
222. 4—Dungen
223. Bonfires on The Heath--The Clientele
224. In The Land of Grey and Pink—Caravan
225. The Pavillion of Dreams--Harold Budd
226. Waking The Dead, Live in Japan 2005--Anekdoten
227. Seven—Magenta
228. Empty Days--Empty Days
229. Viva Boma—Cos
230. Peter Gabriel (1)—Peter Gabriel
231. La notte anche di giorno--La Coscienza di Zeno
232. Songs in The Key of Life—Stevie Wonder
233. Wind and Wuthering—Genesis
234. Get in Touch with Yourself--Swing Out Sister
235. ( ) -- Sigur Rós
236. Ghosts Don't Dance With Shoes--Tree Tops
237. Gifts from Enola--Gifts from Enola
238. Before and After Science--Brian Eno
239. Moonmadness—Camel
240. BJ4—Bob James
241. Seal II--Seal
242. Keep on Doing—The Roches
243. Llyr--Ataraxia
244. Ikaro--Aalto
245. Solar Music (Live)--Grobschnitt
246. Original Soundtrack—Godspell
247. Songs for The Inner Child—Shaina Noll
248. Songs from The Big Chair—Tears for Fears
249. Winds of Devotion--R. Carlos Nakai, Nawang Khechog & Peter Kater
250. Avalon—Roxy Music

251. Pills, Thrills and Bellyaches--Happy Mondays
252. Rites at Dawn--Wobbler
253. Antimemory--Vaneta
254. Waters of Tomorrow—Vespero
255. Identity—Airbag
256. My Favorite Things--John Coltrane
257. Particelle—Lagartija
258. Behind the Sun--Motorpsycho
260. Margot-- Unaka Prong
261. In Sudden Walks—Aisles
262. Babylon—Babylon
263. Talking Book—Stevie Wonder
264. Something/Anything—Todd Rundgren
265…and so we destroyed everything—sleepmakeswaves
266. Welcome to The Pleasure Dome--Frankie Goes to Hollywood
267. Purple Rain—Prince
268. Loloismo--ZA!
269. The Greatest Show on Earth--Airbag
270. Halflights--Starsabout
271. Night and Day—Joe Jackson
272. Ghosts—Frequency Drift
273. Secret Treaties—Blue Öyster Cult
274. Blue Cello—David Darling
275. Lighttown Closure—Fourteen Twenty-six
276. A Secret Wish--Propaganda
277. Falling Forward—Julia Fordham
278. "Orange"—Jeff Beck Group
279. Ágætis Byrjun—Sigur Rós
280. Pretzel Logic--Steely Dan
281. 1984—Anthony Phillips
282. Moth Vellum—Moth Vellum
283. Prelude—Deodato
284. Free Hand—Gentle Giant
285. Power of Love—Luther Vandross
286. Formica Blues—Mono
287. Parachutes—Coldplay
288. Fish Out of Water--Chris Squire
289. Shukuru—Pharoah Sanders
290. Remember The Future—Nektar
291. The Hounds of Love—Kate Bush
292. Kontinuum—Klaus Schulze
293. Recycled—Nektar
294. Quadrophenia—The Who 
295. L’isola di niente—Premiata Forneria Marconi
296. Reverie—Daturah
297. Ragnarök--Ragnarök
298. Suiciety--Methexis
299. Concerto for Piano and Electric Ensemble—Kotebel
300. This Clear Divide--Stare At The Clouds

301. Choirs of The Eye—Kayo Dot
302. Journey to The Centre of The Eye—Nektar
303. Tango Hour—Astor Piazzolo
304. Megalálzottak és Megszomorítottak--After Crying
305. The Dream of The Magic Jongleur—The Psychedelic Ensemble
306. Celebrate Me Home--Kenny Loggins
307. Fourth World Possible Musics, Vol. 2: Dream Theory in Malaya—Jon Hassell & Brian Eno
308. Close to You--The Carpenters
309. The Trouble with Normal—Bruce Cockburn
310. 4 + 4--The Isley Brothers
311. H to He, Who Am The Only One--Van Der Graaf Generator
312. No tengas miedo--Kant Freud Kafka
313. Luna - Faun
314. Häxan -- Dungen
315. Bath—maudlin of The Well
316. Hats--Blue Nile
317. The Age of Plastic--The Buggles
318. Moonflower—Santana
319. Rodrigo's Concerto de Aranjuez--Julian Bream, John Eliot Gardiner and The Monteverdi Orchestra; RCA Gold Seal, 1986.
320. Tapestry—Carole King
321. Thriller—Michael Jackson
322. Carpenters--The Carpenters
323. Rust Never Sleeps—Neil Young
324. Songs from The Breastbone Drum--Domina Catrina Lee
325. Begin Again Original Soundtrack--Gregg Alexander et al.
326. II -- Mother Turtle
327. I Cry, I Smile--Narada Michael Walden
328. You Can't Tune a Fish, But You Can Tune a Piano--REO Speedwagon
329. Sagarmatha—The Appleseed Cast
330. In A Cold Embrace--Battlestations
331. One of These Nights—The Eagles
332. Ad Perpetuum--Antoine Fafard
333. Lightbulb Sun—Porcupine Tree
334. Down to Earth—Nektar
335. Felicité Thosz--Magma
336. Turn of the Cards—Renaissance
337. Octopus—Gentle Giant
338. Voyage of the Acolyte—Steve Hackett
339. Until the Ghosts Are All Gone--Anekdoten
340. I Wash My Soul in The Stream of Infinity—My Brother The Wind
341. I A Moon—North Sea Radio Orchestra 
342. The True Colors of Mars Pt. 2--The Jensen Code
343. Starfire--Jaga Jazzist
344. No Frontiers--Mary Black
345. Whisper Me--Wim Mertens
346. The Magus—Universal Totem Orchestra
347. Awaiting The Sun--Fauns
348. English Electric, Part 1--Big Big Train
349. Innerspeaker--Tame Impala
350. Terminal Twilight—White Willow

351. The Illusion's Reckoning--Mantra Vega
352. 1000 autunni—SKE
353. The Lone Rhino—Adrian Belew
354. All Is Violent, All Is Bright–God Is An Astronaut
355. Zenyattà Mondatta--The Police
356. Overlook—From.UZ
357. Iridule--Yugen
358. Don’t Get Weird on Me, Babe—Lloyd Cole
359. Huascaran--Fermáta
360. The Underfall Yard—Big Big Train
361. The Seer--Swans
362. Il chiarore sorge due volte—Dunwich
363. Of Things and Beings--Lost World Band
365. RoqueForte--Aranis
366. Cherry Five--Cherry Five
367. Not A Good Sign--Not A Good Sign
368. Loveless--My Bloody Valentine
369. Faith--George Michael
370. New Moon Daughter--Cassandra Wilson
371. Morning Sun--Gadi Caplan
372. Technicians of the Sacred--Ozric Tentacles
373. Going for The One—Yes
374. Seven Secrets—Fruupp
375. K.A.—Magma
376. Permutations--The Mercury Tree
377. Belo Horizonte--John McLaughlin
378. Fictions--The Nerve Institute
379. Marsbéli Krónikák--Solaris
380. Bound by the Beauty--Jane Siberry
381. Can't Buy a Thrill--Steely Dan
382. Private Parts & Pieces III: Antiques--Anthony Phillips
383. Flame--Ronnie Laws
384. Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band--The Beatles
385. Waiting for Dawn--Robin Guthrie
386. Second Life Syndrome--Riverside
387. The Way Up--Pat Metheny
388. Silk Degrees--Boz Scaggs
389. Hoelderlin's Traum--Hoelderlin
390. Crisis? What Crisis?--Supertramp
391. Posthumous Silence--Sylvan
392. Careless--Stephen Bishop
393. Discontinuance--Ghost Medicine
394. Spectrum of the Green Morning--Retrospective
395. Sunrise—My Education
396. Rabbit--The Tea Club
397. Under a New Sign—Knight Area
398. Disconcerto Grosso—Khatsaturjan
399. LegEnd--Henry Cow
400. In No Sense? Nonsense!--Art of Noise

401. Encore (Live 1977)—Tangerine Dream
402. Memento z banalnym triptykiem--SBB
403. Stronger than Pride--Sade
404. Eye on The Sunset--Nine Stones Close
405. --EYOT
406. The Sirens Sound—Collapse Under The Empire
407. Meet Danny Wilson--Meet Danny Wilson
408. Before and After Science--Brian Eno
409. Heavy Weather—Weather Report
410. Strinkadenn Ys--Seven Reizh
411. Kid A--Radiohead
412. De Profundis--After Crying
413. Ahora Mazda--Ahora Mazda
414. Peter Gabriel (3)—Peter Gabriel
415. The Third Frontier--Utopianisti
416. Um Himinjǫður--Tirill
417. Lost and Found--KBB
418. Holographic Codex--Alio Die & Lorenzo Montanà
419. The extent of damage--Battlestations
420. Ego, Georgius--Jerzy Antczak
421. Work in Progress--Signal to Noise Ratio
422. Inmazes--Vola
423. Il Giardino delle consuetudini--FEM
424. Life to Come--Redshift
425. Deconsecrated and Pure--Alio Die
426. Heads--Bob James
427. Disclosure--The Gathering
428. The Winstons--The Winstons
429. Les Porches--Maneige
430. Haul Ar Yr Eira--Pererin
431. The Black Tomato--Øresund Space Collective
432. The Sun and The Moon Getting It On--Perplexa
433. The Red Violin soundtrack--Joshua Bell & The Philharmonia Orchestra (John Corigliano, composer)
434. The Seeds of Love--Tears for Fears
435. The Finest of Miracles--Ciccada
436. Hysteria--Def Leppard
437. Transmission from Sogmore's Garden--Magic Bus
438. Ancestor's Tale--Ut Gret
439. Gaucho--Steely Dan
440. A Wizard/A True Star--Todd Rundgren
441. Allas Sak--Dungen
442. Skellig--Mr. Gil
443. Untamed--Ill Wicker
444. Rotvälta--The Spacious Mind
445. The Fall of Bliss--Methexis
446. Clivages--Univers Zero
447. The World Is A Game--Mystery
448. Blue Dogs--Manna/Mirage
450. AKT: II (Binario)

451. Elegant Gypsy—Al DiMeola
452. The Stones of Naples--Corde Oblique
453. Diagonal—Diagonal
454. II--Lunatic Soul
455. Les mortes vont vites--Shub-Niggurath
456. The Fountain Soundtrack--Clint Mansell
457. I—Factor Burzaco
458. Quickly, Quickly, Quickly--The Tea Club
459. Filaments--Robert Rich
460. Blue Dream--Sequentia Legenda
461. Republikflucht!...Facing East--Proteo
462. Licht--Faun
463. Chasing After Shadows... Living with The Ghosts--Hammock
464. Quidam—Quidam
465. Never Forever--Kate Bush
466. Home--Sylvan
467. Coma--Nemo
468. The Clockwork Universe--Thieves' Kitchen
469. Om--Negura Bunget
470. Belighted--Iamthemorning
471. Stranger Inside--Richard Barbieri
472. The Death Defying Unicorn--Motorpsycho
473. Life's Hard and Then You Die--It’s Immaterial
474. Coffins on Io-Kayo Dot
475. Breaking the Circle--Nomads of Hope
476. Veil of Gossamer--Dave Bainbridge
477. Weird Tales--Karda Estra
478. Oranges & Lemons--XTC
479. A Passion Play--Jethro Tull
480. Legendes--Hécénia
481. Streetlife Serenade—Billy Joel
482. Speak--I And Thou
483. Pieces--Cicada
484. The Epic--Kamasi Washington
485. Essenes--Gotic
486. Three--Bob James
487. A Moon Shaped Pool--Radiohead
488. Discontinuance--Ghost Medicine
489. Blow by Blow--Jeff Beck
490. IV--Led Zeppelin
491. Random Avenger--Magyar Posse
492. Here Comes the Sun--Klone
493. Scintilla--NoSound
494. Il misantropo felice--Breznev Fun Club
495. Abel Ganz--Abel Ganz
496. New Worlds--Karda Estra
497. Hermandad--Cabezas de Cera
498. Body and Soul--Joe Jackson
499. Free For All--Art Blakey and The Jazz Messengers
500. Legacy--Hypnos 69

And there are so many more but I'm going to stop at 500. 

P.S. I guess I lean toward the Crossover, Symphonic, Jazz/Fusion and Ambient sides of “progressive music.” I love music.

Friday, April 4, 2014

Top Albums of the Year 2012, Part 2: The Others

Other Albums from 2012 Worth Listening To

ROZ VITALIS Patience of Hope

An collection of odd songs that have trouble fitting into any genre as the music varies--within each song--from Baroque and classical to vaudevillian and King Crimsonian jazz.

Five star songs: 
11. "The Unfading Sun (The Loving Version)" (3:56) the chamber/classical, acoustic/folk version of this song. (10/10) 
3. "To Stir Up Your Pure Minds" (3:10) opens with cello, then clarinet before dulcimer lays down a foundational chord progression for the two to rejoin a pretty weave. (10/10)
2. "The Unfading Sun (The Loved Version)" (2:50) is the electrified piano version of this pretty melody. (9/10)
5. "The Forgiven Monday" (3:36) is a spacey electronic piece (9/10)
9. "Dove il Sole E Meraviglia" (1:57) opens with plucked dulcimer playing solo before being joined by clarinet in a slow pretty song. At the end of the first minute the song picks up speed and adds a cello to weave a classical arrangement together. (9/10)

Four star songs:
10. "Touching Upon the Mystery" (8:55) opens with solo harpsichord before band kicks into a kind of quirky electro-polka. By the fourth minute it has reverted to classical music but then almost as quickly switches back into circus jazz polka and then into a kind of Latin cinematic. Odd song but I like it. (8/10)
7. "Mother of All Rain" (4:28) begins as a simple almost New Age piano étude, before electric guitar and rock combo join in and eventually take over in what ends up being a bit of a heavier number. (8/10)
1. "Patience of Hope" (6:43) is an Arp synth-drenched pensive electric guitar solo (8/10)
6. "Gorgeous Cliff" (1:35) (8/10)

Three star songs: 
4. "Seeds Fell Among Thorns" (6:17) opens with a bit of minimalist feel to it before devolving into an odd Balinese-sounding weirdness. (7/10)
8. "Confidence" (5:53) opens as a classical piano solo piece--another "étude"--before turning vaudeville-jazzier in the second minute. At 1:53 drums, bass and saxophone take over the main melody in a fully jazz effort--though admittedly this takes on a King Crimsonian approach to jazz. Such a simple and unimpressive song. (7/10)  

The King Crimson Lark's Tongue influences are quite recognizable in instrument choices but even more in the sound recording choices: there is a very hollow "old" sound to this album throughout.

84.54 on the Fish scales = solid four star album; an excellent addition to any prog music collection.


Some powerful music all based on very simple, drone-like melodies and rhythms that usually play out start to finish. Alternating vocals, some very nice songs and melodies capped by the album's  opener, "Children of The Sun" (7:33) (10/10), a Brendon vocal.

3.5 stars.

DEAN WATSON Imposing Elements

Wonderful music, full of beautiful melodies and catchy hooks, twists and turns, from this talented multi-instrumentalist. I think what brings me in the most about this album is the way that it deftly crosses and fuses the prog/jazz line. What turns me slightly off is the not quite top-notch engineering, mixing, and production. There is a kind of lack of bleed and background with regards to shifts and changes within songs that, to me, denotes multi-track single artist. There are several artists out there right now doing self-produced self-performed multi-instrumental music (Trurl, David Minasian, The Psychedelic Ensemble, Domina Catrina Lee, Stephen Desbiens, and Pat Metheny and Steven Wilson, [kind of], come to mind immediately). 
     Dean is good but not yet great on the production side of things. A really excellent listen, start to finish, so long as you don't put the headphones on and give it your 100%.

Favorite songs: "Past Present" (6:47) (9/10); "Pendulum" (6:31) (9/10), and; "New Resolution" (8:38) (9/10).

82.5 on the Fish scales = solid four star album, highly recommended to any prog lover.


Oxford's ANTIQUE SEEKING NUNS decides upon a change in course musically and, therefore, a change in the band's name.


A very interesting music of a folk-chamber orientation not unlike NORTH SEA RADIO ORCHESTRA, CARDIACS, AUTUMN CHORUS, or even YUGEN (or its later incarnation, EMPTY DAYS) and some of the more thoughtful, jazzier bands from the 70s Canterbury Scene. Beautiful vocals throughout. Recommended for late-night fireside listening.


As polished production as the previous album, it's amazing to consider that there is only one member remaining from 2007's brilliant Transcendental album--singer, Julie Kiss. Mega kudos, Julie, for holding clear and tight to the original vision of To-Mera! Though the presence of HAKEN keyboard wizard Henshall does seem to have smoothed out the sonic textures of To-Mera's music (except maybe in "Broken"), I'm not sure I like this change--part of what has made me come back again and again to Transcendental is that album's songs' sudden, quirky, and never predictable changes mid-song (not quite as chaotic as those of UNEXPECT, nor ever as heavy), I like this album better than the more recent releases from bands to whom To-Mera are compared--Within Temptation, Epica, Nightwish, After Forever. There are some absolutely gorgeous passages and melodies here.

Lone remainder of the founding group, Julie Kiss, continues to beguile me with her extraordinary voice, and overall I think this album the most accessible of the band’s output, but I’m not sure this is a good thing. Gone are the rough edges, the sharp and sudden turns, everything has been smoothed out. I’m not sure if it’s the keyboard work, but this album has far less of the abrasive, unpredictableness of either Transcendental or Traces. Instead, I feel as if I am listening more to NIGHTWISH or EPICA or WITHIN TEMPTATION. Sometimes the ‘new’ To-Mera is a positive (I often found some of the radical within-song shifts from previous albums disconcerting or distancing—though never so much as within, say, an UNEXPECT song), but I am also saddened at the loss of quirky surprise. Even the songs I find closest to the ‘old’ To-Mera are still surprisingly smooth, melodic, and “pretty.”

So, herein lies the difficulty of the decision to rate this album:  I miss the sudden, drastic mid-song changes in mood, tempo, and/or instrumentation, but I do find myself enjoying the more melodic, smoothness of the new music—especially as added by the keyboard player. And I do not begrudge the group it’s movement away from Heavy Metal. But I do know this:  I love the voice of Julie Kiss, I love the bass playing of Mark Harrington, I love the incorporations of Near Eastern instruments and sounds. I do not like the way the drums sound and often find myself questioning the choice of keyboard sounds (they're often quite cheezy, almost more like PAUL HARDCASTLE).

"Inviting the Storm” (3:02) (8/10)
     “The Illusionist” (7:21) (8/10)
     “The Descent” (7:54) (7/10)
4    “Deep Inside” (6:46) (8/10)
5    “Broken” (10:04) (8/10)
      “End Game” (6:13) (9/10)
       “Surrender” (11:05) (9/10)
8    “All I Am” (12:46) (9/10)

82.5 on the Fish scales = solid four star album. Nice consistency and continued high level creativity.


Listening to this album has been a mixed bag: I enjoy the symphonic and jazz elements of this tremendously but am not an avid fan of heavy prog. Still, this is, to my ears, very good progresssive rock--the vocals being the weakest element of the music, the keyboards being the strongest. While not quite up there with Tool's Lateralus, Karnivool's Sound Awake, Porcupine Tree's Fear of a Blank Planet, and Riverside's Second Life Syndrome; it is on a par with Sylvan's Posthumous Silence, Gösta Berlings Saga's Detta Har Hänt , Rishloo's Feathergun, and Von Hertzen Brothers' Love Remains the Same.

Favorite songs: "Kono Yume" (8:41) (9/10); "Obsession" (9:12) (8/10), and; "Utopia" (12:31) (8/10).

ASTRA The Black Chord

1. "Cocoon" (8:43) is an instrumental song in the space-psychedelic/Komische rock instrumental jam vein. (8/10)

2. "The Black Chord" (14:59) has a gorgeous beginning but the runs into a few rough patches. Nice Yes-like guitar and Mellotron melodies in several places. (9/10)

3. "Black Meat" (6:41) takes a step backwards in terms of sound and structural choices. In my opinion this is a much less mature and well-thought out song with subpar performances that don't gel well. (6/10)

4. "Drift" (4:39) is a soft, low key presentation of simple instrumental support for some interesting layering of vocal harmonies. Interesting but just lacking that melodic sensibility necessary to hook the listener in. (8/10)

5. "Bull Torpis" (2:56) opens with a very RUSH-like familiarity--even though it is keyboard-led and the guitars never get up to Alex LIFESON competency. I fail to see the need or purpose of this one. (6/10)

6. "Barefoot in the Head" (9:13) (9/10) has more of a PINK FLOYD/ELOY sound and feel to it.

The album has a well-produced retro sound with solid performances and meaty compositions but it is lacking the hooks and melodies that would bring me back.


A long though pleasant regurgitation of 1970s PINK FLOYD music.

ELEPHANT9 with Reine Fiske Atlantis

An album of interesting, sometimes engaging songs that seem more loose jams than structured prog.


 This is very much a Flower Kings album: a lot of music; a lot of familiar styles; lyrically trying too hard. What is different about this album is that the band is not trying too hard musically--i.e. while all instrumentalists are flying high, displaying facility and ease, they are blending their sections better than ever and not going too over the top, not being as bombastic as they have. The music seems to flow easily, naturally. While some are raving about the epic, "Numbers," I happen to really enjoy the short songs much more. While "Pandemonium" (9/10) and "Rising the Imperial" ((9/10) are my favorites, all the others save "For Those About to Drown" (6/10) are all worthy of 7 or 8s (out of ten). "For the Love of Gold" (7:26) (8/10); "Fireghosts" (5:50) (7/10); "Going Up" (5:10) (7/10); the bluesy-PINK FLOYDIAN instrumental, "Illuminati" (5:56) (8/10), and; the CLAPTON-like "LoLines" (4:24) (7/10). Virtuosic guitar work throughout. Vocals are more diverse but still a weak point. 

3.5 stars rated up for maturity, complexity, consistency and effort.


The TEA CLUB comparisons are not unfounded.

SYLVAN Sceneries

Good power ballads with great performances on this double CD release. A little too up and down, and heavy when up, for me.


More diverse music and instrumental offerings from these two viruoso musicians from Mexico. The founding trio has now been diminished to a duo as their winds player has left the band, but their musical offerings suffer not. Always fascinating what these guys can do with their multi-instrumental skills. I bet they'd be an amazing band to see live in concert.


A refreshing folkish journey in the vein of Mew, Fleet Foxes, My Morning Jacket, The Clientele, The Flaming Lips, and Radiohead. Though more Indie pop than Crossover Prog, this is still refreshingly creative enough both sonically and compositionally that I will include it within my prog music collection. Kind of like Stereolab, Dungen and doves, their unusual creativity deserves recognition for its 'progressiveness.'

GALAHAD Euphoria

 I'd never heard any music from Galahad until this year. Though this album mostly reminds me of IQ's 2009 Frequency, I have to admit that the music here surprised me quite a bit: especially the presence of modern dance/house music and other 'tricks' from the world of electronica (on the opener, "Salvation 1: Overture" [4:11] [8/10], the album's IQ-like 'epic,' "Guardian Angel" [10:31] [9/10], and "All in the Name of Progress" [7:14] [7/10]); I'm often feeling that I'm listening to a heavier version of the PET SHOP BOYS or the THE. The chameleonic voice of singer Stuart Nicholson sounds so familiar. At times I'm reminded of the lead singer from IQ's 2009 Frequency, Peter Nicholls ("Salvation II: Judgment Day" and "Guardian Angel"), at other times I hear Guy Manning ("All in the Name of Progress"), and still others I hear FISH ("Richlieu's Prayer 2012"), and others like 80s rocker DAVID COVERDALE from WHITESNAKE (on the RUSH-meets-GARY NUMAN-like "Secret Kingdoms ..." [5:31] [7/10]), and even sometimes BLUE ÖYSTER CULT's Eric Bloom. The attempts to imbue the album with some feel of classical music is to my ears quite false and misleading as the piano pieces to which others must be referring are quite simple and straightforward--almost as if accompaniments to marches and other processional pieces; the intros on the last three songs aren't quite what I had in mind when I heard other reviewers mention the "classical influences" on this album. The time signatures here for the greater part also feel quite simple and straightforward. And the use of sounds and instruments from the realm of "heavy prog" sound quite straightforward as lifts from classic rock songs and stylings from the 1980s. I am impressed with the band's ability to gather, draw and synthesize sounds and elements from many diverse origins in rock/music history. However, I think that the smoothness with which they blend these styles and sounds can be improved upon.

Nice work that most proggers will enjoy--especially if you've a predisposition to Neo-prog.

3.5 stars rated up for its creative surprises.

SHADOW CIRCUS On a Dark and Stormy Night

This is a theatric album of heavier rock that synthesizes and regurgitates some pretty obvious classic and prog rock sounds, stylings, and riffs. The result of this synthesis is often odd, surprising, and awkward. Sometimes it works. There is a lot of pleasant, if familiar, music to listen to here with one particular gem worth citing: the delicate and beautiful instrumental, "Ixchel."

1. The opening instrumental, "Overture" (5:57), has quite a RUSH feel to it--especially the final five minutes. I like the spacey first two-and-a-half minutes best. (7/10)

2. "Daddy's Gone" (5:57) A voice and singing style quite similar to that of NOEL McCALLA (of Mike Rutherford Smallcreep's Day fame) As a matter of fact, other than the guitar lead and the drum work, this song has quite a Smallcreep feel to it. Like the full use of the background synths on this. (8/10)

3. "Whosit, Whatsit, & Which" (6:34) has an awesome spacious, spacey first minute before a very standard bluesy 70s-ish guitar and Rhodes piano chord and A-B construct establish themselves. The singing this time sounds more like GUY MANNING with PINK FLOYD's famed Dark Side of the Moon background singers providing the support. I actually get bored with the way the keyboard and Peter Frampton-like electric guitar (by the way: I rather like P.F.'s guitar sound and styling) constantly mirror one another throughout instrumental cadences and interludes. (7/10)

4. "Make Way for the Big Show" (8:42) is the album's longest song. It begins with quite a nice piano intro in a pseudo classical Broadway musical-like style. At 1:37 the song shifts into rock mode with electric guitars and organ becoming part of the support. The rock portions of this album are beginning to sound so familiar. Halfway between ANDREW LLOYD-WEBBER's Phantom of the Opera and some of LOVERBOY's stuff from the late 70s. Or perhaps like today's hot new prog phenom, HAKEN. The piano and organ play, in particular, are particularly theatric/operatic.

5. "Tesseract" (5:20) is a CORVUS STONE-like instrumental that begins with quite an engaging, if familiar, pulse. The initial guitar soli/playing are also engaging, if very 70s-ish (Loverboy, Led Zeppelin). Little musical development is necessary in this one as it is really a vehicle for instruments to solo and show off their tight chops. A great recapturing of that 1970s metal sound and feel. (8/10)

6. "Uriel" (5:51) begins with piano, synths and cello weaving a loose, melodic tapestry which is then joined by the guitars and rhythm section at the end of the first minute to give us another kind of Smallcreep song. Pretty, syrupy, and pretentious. The singer is not quite up to the Noel McCalla skill level. The song shift at 2:50 is refreshing . . . until the singer/lyric and synth join in. Standard chord progressions and rock hooks throughout. (7/10)

The transition into song 7. "Camozotz" (6:23) is my favorite part of the album. But then, at the one minute point, a bouncy vaudevillian piano ruins it for me. The rhythm shift at 1:40 is equally awkward and mysterious. I actually enjoy the treated vocal--but don't really appreciate or understand the use of the Clare Torey/DSotMoon female background vocals. The 3:20 shift to ROGER WATERS-style music and vocal is again, nothing short of odd and awkward. Then at 4:10 a classic RUSH-like section ensues. Wild song! Wild ride! Quite a cut-and-paste imagination! The final minute, I have to admit, really works--screaming treated vocal with screaming background lead guitar over slow, hard-driving rhythm section. A classic Pink Floyd ending! (8/10)

8. "Ixchel" (4:40) changes things up a bit with a very beautiful STEVE HACKETT-like nylon-string guitar intro. At 1:25 synths and guitar enter in a slow volume and entry- and decay-controlled fashion. At 2:40 multi-layered voices (male and female) beautifully mirror the piano's right hand melody. Then 'strings' take a turn doing the same mirroring and support job, finishing, then, with the voices and piano. A gorgeous, delicate, mature song. (10/10)

9. The album's final song, "The Battle for Charles Wallace"(7:00) is another re-visitation to the realm of classic 1970s blues-rock as so well put together by another 2012 album, CORVUS STONE's eponymously titled debut album. After a nice three-minute intro, the song shifts into an almost straightforward "it must be love" rock song. At 3:45 a 25 second burst of whole-band syncopated heavy metal power chords takes us in another direction. But then at 4:10 we are treated to a section of multi-layer rondo- and MOON SAFARI-like vocals. At 5:50 we are treated to a cool upper register electric guitar arpeggio riff to shift us into the finale mode--ascending and descending electric guitar scales over thick, heavy Phantom of the Opera organ. (I wonder: Are the theatric, Phantom-like similarities and flourishes intentional or accidental?) Weird song that kind of works. (8/10) 

Nicely crafted, well-produced recreation of 1970s heavy-yet syrupy theatric melodic rock in the STYX/LOVERBOY/HAKEN vein.

As my reviews of 2012 album acquisitions comes nearer to the end I have to say that the trend I am feeling from today's "prog rockers" is more of incorporation, assimilation, synthesis, replication, regurgitation with some re-interpretation of older prog and classic rock themes, sounds and styles. This is not necessarily a bad thing, but it does leave one with a bit of a let down because there is this constant feeling of "heard this before" or "this isn't anything really new." If this is what it takes for modern bands to grow and internalize the roots of progressive rock in order to, then, crysalize and morph into their own innovative, uniquely creative "progressors" of (rock) music, then so be it. I will gladly wait out this evolutionary period--I await the emergence of new, fully-formed and independent . . . butterflies.

3RDEGREE The Long Division

have to admit that I was quite suspicious of a band's rating when its new album release starts climbing the charts due to the fact that no less than 9 out of the 13 entries in the "Latest members reviews" column are PA newbies who joined only to post a review of this one album (and two of the other four have rated less than ten albums and reviewed only one:  this one and of the less than ten albums the list is suspiciously the same!) It's nice to have fans, nice to have a group helping to get your name and music out there. Whatever it takes, I guess. Time will obviously help this album settle into its true place among the releases of 2012.

Curious, I found their album on Bandcamp. And I've been listening.

1. "You're Fooling Yourselves" (6:51) sounds like a kind of DISCIPLINE-as-THE BEATLES classic rocker. There is a cute carnival-esque section beginning at the 2:56 mark followed by a SAGA-like semi-rap with vocal harmonies. Great section in the guitar solo beginning at the 4:40 mark. The vocalist does a pretty great job sounding like JOHN LENNON, revved-up PAUL McCARTNEY and early ROD STEWART. (8/10)

2. "Exit Strategy" (5:45) is a very perky, poppy STEELY DAN-meets-XTC to play THE TEA CLUB song. Truly some great multiple vocal arrangements here. Nice keyboard/mellotron and bass parts. A very catchy, cute song. (9/10)

3. "The Socio-Economic Petrie Dish" (6:52) is the weakest song on the album in its cheezy keyboards and poppy-pseudo-prog structure. Again I am reminded of STEELY DAN 1972- 75, pre-Aja. A very mediocre song'even with the melodramatic 'Occupy' crowd sample in the final minute. (5/10)

4. "Incoherent Ramblings" (7:44) begins with a vocal melody that fails to connect. Once the song establishes its support structure it doesn't get much better. It's almost like an average BEACH BOYS or a bad XTC song. (7/10)

5. "The Ones to Follow" (3:12) is a cute pop song in the vein of XTC and GEORGE HARRISON. (7/10)

6. "A Work of Art" (2:50) begins with some arpeggiated electric piano chords before weaving in some other subtle instruments, vocals, and eventually saxophone. The keyboard sound brings me back to some of RONNIE LAWS' proggier stuff in the late 70s (around the "Always There" and Flame period). (7/10)

7. "Televised" (6:52) with its old synth sounds harkens back to some late 70s classic rock songs. When the song kicks into high gear around the 1:50 mark it is definitely treading on MATTHEW PARMENTER/DISCIPLINE territory. Then a clavichord enters! Surprises abound in this one: falsetto vibratos, Motown-like female b vox. As the song progresses it morphs again into more XTC ground. An unusual but kind of intriguing mix. Perhaps the most original song on the album. (8/10)

8. "The Millions of Last Moments" (2:06) starts out very much like KANSAS' "Dust in the Wind" before a jazzy CHET ATKINS-like electric guitar joins in. A pretty instrumental guitar duet. (7/10)

9. "Memetic Pandemic" (7:29) begins with a bare piano, joined by a GEDDY LEE-like voice before morphing into a GENESIS/BIG BIG TRAIN/ECHOLYN-like song. Interesting ECHOLYN/ BEATLES-like vocal harmonies. Love the GENESIS picked electric guitar interlude at the 1:45 mark and the MIKE OLDFIELD-like fuzz guitar playing in tandem with the early-TONY BANKSian synthesizer that follows. Despite the "There Must be Some Misunderstanding" bass line and chord the next section, this song develops and catches one very much like a very good ECHOLYN song. The drumming on this one stands out for me: PHIL COLLINS-ish. The section that begins at 5:15 is great for its organ, b-vox, and GENESIS-era P GABRIEL vocal. The last minute and a half enters into more of a BEATLES feel. (9/10)

10. "A Nihilist's Love Song" (3:21) starts out with a lyric and melody that reminds me of a choral version of TODD RUNDGREN's "Just One Victory." As it goes on I am more reminded of JON BON JOVI. (8/10)

I am pleasantly surprised to find that this is, in fact, an interesting album--especially for its varied collection of sounds and influences. It is, however, a little more pop oriented than I expected. My favorite songs are definitely the perky "Exit Strategy" and the ECHOCLYN-like "Memetic Pandemic." As a matter of fact, if one were to try to extract the essence of this album, it would be the XTC, STEELY DAN, and ECHOLYN familiarities. I actually like this album better than the much-praised 2012 Echolyn release, Echolyn. (Ironic that the BRETT KULL-mixed "You're Fooling Yourself" is not even, IMO, the most ECHOLYN-sounding song on the album!)

78.0 on the Fish scales = 3.5 stars rated up for factors of intrigue and quirkiness.

Albums from 2012 that Are, IMHO, Over-rated


 I am very happy for the success of Frequency Drift as I have loved following the recent arrival and evolution of the band, from cinematic/soundtrack music to 2011's masterpiece, Ghosts.... They are an immensely talented, wonderfully creative band. But, try as hard as I have, (I've owned Laid to Rest for several months now), this 2012 release does not please me, does not draw me in or amaze me half as well as Ghosts... did/does. A lot of the dynamic shifts have been watered down, the band seems to have moved more toward a softer, more drawn out, slow development approach to composition and performance. I find myself waiting for the peaks, waiting for the dramatic shifts, even waiting for the magical weaves of multiple instruments that I so loved on Ghosts.... But they are not there. Over and over, weeks apart I've returned to this album saying to myself that I must be missing something, that I must be in the wrong mood or that I'm just not giving it my fullest attention. The posting of this review is my admission that I am finished trying. Laid to Rest is being laid to rest. I'm so sorry.

3 stars.

DIAGONAL The Second Mechanism

The production is GREATLY improved, however, musically The Second Mechanism is quite disappointing since I LOVED their debut. This one is not so classic, not so raw, and it's more syrupy and slow--not bad, just never as great or fresh or driving as the first one. Also, I rather liked the "dirty" production of the first album, this one is so clean and pristine (which is nice, I must admit, for the spacious, softer [more KARDA ESTRA/CAMEL-like] parts).

Favorite songs: the ANEKDOTEN-like "These Yellow Sands" (7:59) (8/10), "Mitochondria" (9:41) (9/10), and "Hulks" (10:35) (8/10) (horns and fem b vox), and the eerily mood-capturing, CURE-ish "Capsizing" (9:10) (9/10).

An excellent prog album, just not up to the pace set forth by their first one. Still, recommended. (Just try to take it on its own terms--forget the dynamism of the first release.)

 VESPERO Subkraut: U-Boats Welcome Here

Nowhere near the quality or emotional impact of their previous studio or live albums. The music here feels more rhythm driven rather than rhythm explorative, or improvisational, as I felt on By The Waters of Tomorrow and their live albums. I do not like the direction this band has chosen to go.

SILHOUETTE Across the Rubycon

As I listen to this album (again) I'm reminded as to why I've never rated their previous albums very highly: I do not enjoy the plugged-direct-to-computer versus microphone-recorded sounds and recording techniques, the RUSH- and SURVIVOR-like rock feel, and the ALAN PARSONS PROJECT feeling of the variety of lead vocalists used. There is nothing exceptional here and a lot of music that is imitative of what I call "second-tier" or "prog-related" rockers from the 70s, 80s and 90s. The stuff is okay, it's just that there is nothing here calling me back (though I've gone back now several times over the past couple of months). Definitely not 'essential' listening.


After several dedicated listens through this album over the past few months I am finally ready to post a review of this highly acclaimed album from 2012. An instrumental album in the vein of OZRIC TENTACLES, HYPNOS69 and QUANTUM FANTAY with a little more emphasis and volume given to the drums and computer-generated sounds and keyboards and a little less emphasis on predictable melody and structure. (This is no jam band!) While I have enjoyed my listens, and have been entertained and engrossed in their sound (especially the computer keyboard work), and I do appreciate the passion coming from the drummer, it is doubtful that I will find myself returning to this album very often.

1. “Houndstooth, Part 1"–starts out sounding a bit like one of my favorite alubmartists, STEREOLAB’s Dots and Loops before the organ is joined by some psychedelic fuzz guitar, computerized drum sounds and rhythms, and builds into what is obviously an instrumental. Kind of cool. (8/10)

2. “Houndstooth, Part 2”—keeps the 60s fuzz/treated guitar and bass sounds with live acoustic drums and some KRAFTWERK/OMD-like keyboard sounds all packaged into a kind of 60s psych pop or 80s bubble gum TONY BASIL-like sound and feel. Happy and psychedelic even a little bluesy. (7/10)

3. “Expo ‘67”—sounds like a new version of EDGAR WINTER’s “Frankenstein” to me. Same instruments, same riffs, same structure. (7/10)

4. “Flossing with Buddha”—birds and church organ start out this one before it turns into a kind of Brit-pop song again straddling the late 60s and the bubble gum pop of the 80s. (Lulu, The Buckinghams, Adam Ant, Yaz, The The.) (7/10)

5. “Message from Uncle Stan Grey Shirt”—some of Mahogony Frog’s intros, like this one, remind me of fellow Canadians, GODSPEED YOU! BLACK EMPEROR. Lots of chaos and cacophony—like an orchestra tuning before a concert. Uncle Stan (in the Grey Shirt) must be totally wasted cuz this song is all about chaos and really having a slow and tough time (being able to) getting it together. Finally, a kind of "House of the Rising Sun" meets "Pomp and Circumstanc"e pulls itself up out of the dross and then morphs into a “This Is The Doors” cover band intro for the final two minutes. Interesting. And psychedelic. (7/10)

6. “Messsage from Uncle Stan Green House”—starts out with a rather striking JAGA JAZZIST sound to it. Indecipherable babel of voices accompanies the music for a little while until it all descends into a slowed down, heavily sound-effects-accompanied heroine trip. Ends on a structured note. (6/10)

7. “Saffron Myst”—is a melodic, almost laid-back tune with synths/organ featured. Again, I am reminded of STEREOLAB and especially Dots and Loops. (8/10)

8. “Aqua Love Ice Cream Delivery Service”—carries over the synth trails from “Saffron Myst” while turning them into virulent crazy with a Todd Rundgren-like organ wash beneath to keep them all tied together. The guitar’s entry at 2:35 is wonderful and continues to build within the tornadic frenzy of the other crazed musicians. Again, I am reminded of some of TODD’s more adventurous experimentations with sound and noises in his early 1970s solo works. I even half expected it to end with the baton taps and Todd’s voice saying, “No! No! No! A little more humanity, please!” as he does at the end of “The Spark of Life.” But, no! The song quiets down, goes cyber-space crazy before a harpsichord enters to “restore” order—and fadeout the album! (8/10)

A highly creative album laced with psychedelia reminiscent of all of the past four decades’ technological and sound advances. This is not an album I will come back to as often as the above cited space/psychedelic artists because of a certain lack of, well, melody. But I will revisit it for the smiles and curiosities it generates.

3.5 stars rated up for creativity, uniquity and courage.


This heavily praised album is, for me, missing the grit, life, and grist of other echolyn albums. It is a collection of homogenized skim milk. It is simple, thin, watered down prog, albeit pleasant but lacking substance, lacking warmth. It's like kissing your sister, like a fourth place finish at the Olympics, like the taste of artichoke without butter. The first song takes six and a half minutes to hook you in and then just teases you until the final two minutes (which are, I must admit, sublime). My favorite two songs, "Past Gravity" (7:10) (9/10) and "Speaking in Lampblack" (10:45) (8/10) are both pleasant, rather laid back, kind of STEELY DAN/BILLY JOEL-like mainstream-friendly compositions. The album's final two minutes of barbershop fun make me wonder if the band has any more left to give--kind of a feeling I get through this entire listening experience: life is hard, maybe it's time to die. 

1. Island (16:38) (7/10)
2. Headright (3:00) (8/10)
3. Locust To Bethlehem (5:11) (8/10)
4. Some Memorial (11:54) (7/10)
5. Past Gravity (7:11) (9/10)
6. When Sunday Spills (8:48) (8/10)
7. Speaking In Lampblack (10:45) (9/10)
8. The Cardinal And I (7:20) (8/10)

3 stars. At the most.


A benign flow of Indian-influenced Buddha-lounge-like space music with some nice grooves. Overall this album is dismissible in terms of prog contributions go.

THRESHOLD March of Progress

Well-performed heavy rock/lite metal which cries back to the classic rockers of the 70s and 80s like JOURNEY and OZZIE OSBORNE. Again I am plagued by my questioning of the placement of this rather straightforward music within the realm of "progressive" rock. The sounds are polished, the vocals strong and Ozzie-like, but these sounds and vocals fail to match up with the structural the band seems to be trying to work with. There are many decent songs on this album, including "Liberty Complacency Dependency" (7:48) (8/10) (politics!), "Colophon" (6:00) (9/10), "That's Why We Came" (5:40) (8/10), "Don't Look Down" (8:12) (8/10) (I don't like the chorus/harmonized vocals), and my favorite, "Coda" (5:23) (9/10), but then there are several that, to my ears, never rise above sounding like the average stuff from the the 80s, and "Divinity" (6:27) (7/10) seems a direct rip off from the work of MAYNARD JAMES KEENAN (especially PUCIFER). Still, nice work for the listeners of Octane radio.

I agree with other reviewers: nice use of keyboards.

3 stars.


Okay, here I go (again): Getting on my soapbox to incur the wrath and ire of fellow music lovers. sorry. I have honestly been listening to this music for over a month (though I must admit that I can only take a song or two at a time). Exactly how is this music good? Haven't you all read the books by Dr. Musaru Emoto and Alfred Tomatis and Joseph Campbell and Ram Dass: This kind of cacophony causes chaos and entropy, destruction and death! Even if I could find anything redeeming about this 'singing,' these 'vocals,' these lyrics, the music is so simplistic, so straightforward and so derivative of 70s rockers like BLUE OYSTER CULT and 90s innovator CYNIC that I don't get the grounds for all this praise! Even the Jem Godfrey/Frost* sounding "Storm of Memories" (8:57) (8/10) has a promising beginning with fewer doom/death growling (at least for the first three minutes). Unfortunately, it's all downhill from there. Machine gun drums and machine gun guitars. I just don't get it. Maybe as a caffeine or cocaine substitute this works for some people, but for what reason? Are we really that angst-ridden--that forlorn and lost--as a culture that this is the only outlet we can devise for our frustrations? 
     I am a believer that music is an expression of highest creativity, our highest art form with which to bridge material with spiritual. This kind of music is, to my mind, a slap in the face to all the great composers, artists and creators in human history. What a shame! What a waste of talent and potential (obviously, the players can play, their minds have creative capacity. I guess I should be looking at all this entropy and chaos as the Taoist balance to all the Light and Beauty, or as Karl Jung might: Out of shit the alchemist creates gold!) 

Sorry, boys. I'll take Brahms' 3rd, Satie's "Gymnopedie," Renaissance's Novella, LeGrand's Pastorales de Noël, Bill Evans' Village Vangaurd recordings, Cocteau Twins' Tiny Dynamine, and any Baroque music over this, any day.